TLDR
- CFTC nominees Matthew Rowland and Nathan Anonick appeared before the Senate Agriculture Committee on November 17.
- The CFTC has one commissioner instead of five, and its staff has shrunk by about 25%.
- Both nominees said the agency needs more staff and a full commission.
- They agreed prediction market rules need to be clearer but stressed different priorities.
- The CFTC ordered Kalshi to pause bets on presidential remarks and is investigating Polymarket.
The U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission has one commissioner and about a quarter fewer workers than before. Two nominees told senators on Tuesday that they want to fix both problems.
Matthew Rowland and Nathan Anonick appeared before the Senate Agriculture Committee on November 17. President Donald Trump nominated both men last week.
Rowland is the Democratic nominee, and Anonick is the Republican nominee. There is talk they could be confirmed before the current session of Congress ends.
A Commission Running on One Seat
The CFTC is designed to have five commissioners. Right now it runs with only one, Chairman Mike Selig.
Both nominees said the commission should return to full strength. Anonick said filling the empty seats would help the agency write stable and lasting policy.
The agency’s workforce has shrunk by about 25% under recent federal downsizing. At the same time, its oversight work has grown to cover areas such as digital assets and prediction markets.
Both nominees said they could look at ways to add staff to match the workload. They agreed the agency needs more people to supervise the markets it oversees.
Different Paths on Prediction Markets
The nominees also agreed that the rules for prediction markets need to be clearer. These markets let users trade contracts tied to future events.
Rowland said federal law requires the agency to weigh the public interest of certain event contracts. He said oversight should balance market growth with protection for users.
He added that, if confirmed, he would help build a set of rules made for prediction markets. Anonick took a different focus and said legal fights are making the rules harder to apply.
Anonick said he would follow the Supreme Court once it rules on the key questions. Federal and state governments are in conflict over who regulates platforms run by companies like Kalshi, Polymarket and Coinbase.
Some federal courts have treated sports event contracts as state gambling matters. Other courts have backed the CFTC’s authority over federally regulated derivatives exchanges.
Senators raised concerns that business ties between the Trump family and prediction market companies could affect fair oversight. Both nominees said the law must apply equally, no matter a company’s political links.
Outside the hearing, the CFTC has stepped into about 12 state lawsuits, including one in Louisiana. It is defending prediction markets against claims of unlicensed gambling, and it has also opened a broad investigation into Polymarket.
The agency recently ordered Kalshi to pause “mention markets,” which are bets on what the president will say. These contracts have small trading volume but draw attention on social media.
The order follows a case involving Gabriel Perez, who earlier this year ran the president’s teleprompter. Perez settled with federal regulators over claims he used nonpublic information to profit from bets on presidential speeches.
Kalshi is reportedly planning to halt the contracts indefinitely, citing market integrity. The company plans to keep other markets tied to the administration.
Bets are still trading on the vice president’s future remarks and whether a senior official resigns this year. Contracts on the commerce secretary’s time in office also remain open.
