TLDR
- A Louisiana judge issued an emergency order on November 12 against Kalshi and 31 other firms.
- The order also covers clearing and brokerage firms, and contracts on elections and awards.
- Kalshi had asked a federal judge for protection hours before the state order came through.
- The US government and the CFTC sued Louisiana on November 13 to block the order.
- A hearing on the state order is set for November 30.
Louisiana’s emergency court order against prediction markets goes beyond Kalshi. The order covers 32 companies, including firms that clear, settle and broker trades on federally regulated exchanges.
A judge in the 21st Judicial District Court in Tangipahoa Parish granted the order on the evening of November 12. Louisiana got the order without first notifying the affected companies, a step known as an ex parte temporary restraining order.
What Louisiana’s Order Covers
The order bars the 32 entities from listing, accepting, clearing, settling, brokering or making a market in any “event contract” for people in Louisiana. The ban applies to anyone without a valid state license and permit.
The order is not limited to sports. It also applies to contracts tied to elections, awards and other events.
Because it names clearing and brokerage firms, the order reaches the systems that support federal derivatives markets. Those markets are overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).
Louisiana treats these contracts as wagers under its gambling laws. The state holds that view no matter how the exchanges are registered at the federal level.
Louisiana’s licensing rules require sports bets to be handled inside the state, including where processing servers are located. Kalshi says those rules cannot work for a national exchange supervised by the CFTC.
A Race Between State and Federal Courts
Kalshi had already moved against the state before the order was issued. On October 23, it sued Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill and other officials, arguing that the Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC sole authority over its contracts.
On November 12, Kalshi asked a federal judge for a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction. The company said talks with state officials led it to believe Louisiana would soon act in state court.
Kalshi told the court it faced “imminent criminal, administrative, and forfeiture exposure.” Its filing does not show that it asked the federal court to act without notifying Louisiana.
The state order arrived later that same evening. Kalshi then showed Louisiana users a message saying the state had cut off access “without a hearing, notice, or due process.”
Emergency orders can be issued without notice or a hearing in some cases. The open question is whether Louisiana met the legal standard to do so.
Marshall Cohen called Kalshi’s message misleading on X, saying the judge found advance notice was not needed. Kalshi’s Jovy Dedaj replied that there was in fact no notice and no hearing. He called the step too harsh for an industry that had operated in Louisiana for years.
On November 13, the United States and the CFTC sued Louisiana in the Eastern District of Louisiana. The suit seeks to block the state order and stop Louisiana from applying gambling laws to federally regulated trades.
It says Louisiana chose emergency state action instead of letting existing federal cases move forward. It also says the state’s actions “inject uncertainty into federal derivatives markets.”
Federal courts have split on the core legal question. Kalshi won a favorable Third Circuit ruling involving New Jersey but lost cases involving Ohio and Tennessee, and a New York federal judge rejected its preemption argument.
Much depends on whether sports event contracts count as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act. Kalshi says they do.
For now, Louisiana’s restrictions remain in place while the federal suit is pending. A hearing on the state order is scheduled for November 30.
