TLDR
- Pennsylvania’s gaming board says skill-game operators never disclosed where their machines were or how many were running.
- That gap makes it hard to test PENN Entertainment’s claim that former skill-game players are visiting its casinos.
- In June, Citizens JMP Securities projected a $21 million EBITDA boost for PENN under a 10% revenue-uplift scenario.
- A gambling lawyer and a state lawmaker question whether players are actually moving to casinos.
- Property-level October casino revenue data is expected as early as November 17 or 18.
Pennsylvania’s gaming regulator says it has no way to map where unlicensed skill games operated before a statewide crackdown. That gap makes it hard to test PENN Entertainment’s claim that former skill-game players are now visiting its casinos.
Doug Harbach, communications director for the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board, said skill-game operators never disclosed where their machines were placed or how many were running. He told Gambling Insider that comparing casinos by nearby machine density was “really impossible” for that reason.
The crackdown follows the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s June 15 ruling that skill games count as slot machines under state law. The court allowed a 120-day grace period, and police enforcement began October 14.
On November 10, state police said 12,134 of 12,202 inspected establishments no longer had skill-game machines. That is a 99.4% compliance rate, and officers seized 14 devices and $1,913.
What PENN and Analysts Have Said
PENN CEO Jay Snowden said on the company’s November 5 earnings call that October brought its strongest year-over-year gaming revenue growth in Pennsylvania in 2026. He said he did not think that was a coincidence.
Snowden also indicated the company was seeing more visitors, including former skill-game players, and planned to increase marketing to them. His public remarks did not say how many of those customers there were.
In June, Citizens JMP Securities named PENN the largest potential winner from the crackdown. Under a 10% revenue-uplift scenario, it estimated PENN could gain $21 million in EBITDA, compared with $7 million for Boyd Gaming and $5 million for Churchill Downs.
Analysts Jordan Bender and Isabelle Slavin estimated the state had between 70,000 and more than 100,000 skill-game machines. They based a 10% to 15% slot win increase range on Kentucky and Virginia, which have restricted similar machines. Citizens reportedly revisited its view on November 6 and said it was encouraged by early results.
Why Experts Want More Data
Dmitri Mihhailov, general partner at gambling law firm Prifinance, said he has seen no credible evidence that players have migrated. He pointed out that police only reported near-full compliance on November 10, leaving little data from after the machines were removed.
Mihhailov suggested comparing slot revenue at casinos near many former skill-game sites with casinos near fewer. If gains were equal everywhere, he said, that would point to market growth rather than migration.
State Rep. Russ Diamond, a Republican, said casino and skill-game customers are different groups. Skill games sat in bars, gas stations and convenience stores, where people could play without planning a trip.
September data offers a baseline before enforcement began. Pennsylvania’s regulated market took in about $555 million that month, up 4.07% from a year earlier, with retail slots up 2.44% to $196.2 million.
PENN’s Hollywood Casino at Penn National Race Course saw retail slot revenue fall 2.95% to $10.2 million in September. Online casino revenue under its license rose 12.93% to about $99 million. Hollywood Casino at the Meadows posted a 0.49% retail slot gain.
Mihhailov also noted that casinos pay a $50 million initial license fee plus a 34% tax on gross terminal revenue. He expects them to oppose any less restrictive licensing system for skill games.
The Board expects to publish property-level October revenue figures as early as November 17 or 18. Those numbers will show how each casino performed, but not whether new spending came from former skill-game players.
