TLDR
- Nine Senate Democrats sent a letter to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig on Nov. 16.
- They asked the agency to stop its push to oversee sports event contracts.
- The senators said Selig’s order came hours after a court ruling on tribal lands.
- They asked the CFTC to preserve all related records dating back to Jan. 1, 2025.
- Democrats will control both chambers of Congress starting in January.
Nine Senate Democrats have asked the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to keep every record tied to its handling of sports event contracts. The request was part of a letter sent to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig on Nov. 16.
The lawmakers also asked the agency to drop its push to oversee sports event contracts offered on prediction markets. These contracts let users trade on the outcome of games and have become popular on the platforms.
The letter came less than two weeks after Selig told prediction market operators to stop following geographic restrictions for 30 days. Those restrictions block certain contracts in states that treat them as gambling.
Senators Question Timing of CFTC Order
The senators said Selig’s order arrived only hours after a federal court in the Northern District of California issued a ruling. That court said a major prediction market operator must geofence around tribal lands.
The case was brought by the Blue Lake Rancheria Tribe. The senators said the timing raised concerns that the commission may be working with platforms involved in active lawsuits.
The lawmakers said the order could encourage platforms to break state and tribal gaming laws. They asked the CFTC to withdraw the order or freeze it until the court cases are settled.
The senators also said the order conflicts with court rulings in California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington. Senators from those four states make up eight of the letter’s nine signers.
They argued that many courts have found sports event contracts are not swaps. Instead, those courts have treated them as sports bets that fall under state and tribal gaming laws.
The senators said the CFTC’s reading of impartial access rules would push designated contract markets to offer these products in all 50 states. They said this would happen without regard to state laws, tribal laws or court decisions.
Records Request Covers Nearly Two Years
The letter asked the commission to preserve all records and communications on the topics raised, dating back to Jan. 1, 2025. The senators also asked the agency to keep saving new materials on an ongoing basis.
The request covers records held by the commission itself. It also covers any person or group representing the agency or claiming to act for it.
All signers represent states with deep ties to commercial casinos or tribal gaming. Michigan and Nevada have large commercial casino industries, while California, Minnesota and Washington have strong tribal gaming ties.
California Sens. Alex Padilla and Adam Schiff both signed the letter. California is home to some of the largest tribal casinos in the country.
Schiff has long criticized sports event contracts. Earlier this month, he said the contracts are sports wagers and that the CFTC was “once again violating state law and Tribal sovereignty.”
Nevada senators also signed the letter. The state has taken a firm stance against sports event contracts.
Schiff and Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan sit on the Senate Agriculture Committee, which oversees the CFTC. Sen. Amy Klobuchar, another signer and committee member, was elected governor of Minnesota.
Democrats will control both chambers of Congress starting in January. It is not yet clear how the Agriculture Committee’s membership will change.
