TLDR
- The Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 for Maryland in its case against Kalshi on Tuesday.
- The two judges in the majority each based their opinions on different legal questions.
- The dissenting judge found that sports contracts are swaps and that federal law overrides state rules.
- Maryland may now sue Kalshi in state court to ban its sports contracts.
- Kalshi’s response to New Jersey’s Supreme Court petition is due Dec. 7.
A federal appeals court ruled for Maryland in its fight with Kalshi on Tuesday, but the three judges could not agree on why. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit voted 2-1 to uphold a lower court ruling against the prediction market.
The Fourth Circuit is now the third federal appeals court to side with a state against Kalshi. The ruling affirms a decision by Maryland’s federal district court, which in August 2025 became the first federal court to back a state on sports event contracts.
Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker voted in Maryland’s favor. Each wrote a separate opinion based on a different legal question.
Judge DeAndra Gist Benjamin dissented. She found that sports contracts are swaps and that federal law overrides state gambling rules.
Two Judges, Two Different Reasons
Gregory looked at whether the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state gambling laws and found that it does not. He rejected Kalshi’s claim that Congress gave the Commodity Futures Trading Commission sole control over these contracts.
The law gives the CFTC “exclusive jurisdiction” over certain swap transactions. Gregory said that language must be read alongside a “special rule” letting the agency ban gaming contracts, and a CFTC rule saying exchanges “shall not” list them.
He noted that Kalshi self-certified its sports contracts rather than getting direct approval. In his view, they keep trading only because the CFTC has not ordered them removed.
Thacker focused on whether sports contracts count as swaps at all. She concluded they do not.
Federal law defines a swap as depending on the “occurrence” of an event. Thacker said a sports contract pays based on the result of a game, not on whether the game happens, so it falls outside that definition.
Benjamin disagreed with both colleagues. She wrote that a team winning can be both an outcome and an occurrence, and that the special rule gives the CFTC authority over gaming contracts. She did find that parlays and prop bets are not swaps because they lack enough economic impact.
A Kalshi spokesperson told InGame the “splintered decision” shows there is “no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets.” The company can ask the full Fourth Circuit to rehear the case or appeal to the Supreme Court.
What Comes Next for Maryland
Maryland had agreed not to enforce its gambling laws against Kalshi until the appeals court ruled. The state may now sue Kalshi in state court and seek to ban its sports contracts.
Nevada, Michigan, Washington and Louisiana have already won court orders blocking sports contracts. Those rulings forced prediction markets to geofence users in those states.
Earlier this month, the CFTC told exchanges that geofencing could break its core principles. It is not yet clear whether the agency will allow it when a state court orders it.
North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia and West Virginia also sit in the Fourth Circuit. Those states may now have a clearer path to ban sports contracts.
Other appeals courts are also split. The Third Circuit ruled for Kalshi 2-1, while the Ninth Circuit found that sports contracts are not swaps because they lack enough financial consequences.
In September, New Jersey asked the Supreme Court to hear its appeal of the Third Circuit case. Kalshi asked for more time to respond, and its filing is now due Dec. 7.
