TLDR
- Evolution settled with New Jersey law firm Calcagni & Kanefsky, and a court approved the deal on November 17.
- Black Cube is now the only defendant at this stage of Evolution’s defamation lawsuit.
- The settlement terms are confidential, and it is unclear whether money changed hands.
- Playtech shares fell as much as 10% before recovering after news of the settlement.
- Evolution could still try to add Playtech to the case once Black Cube’s dismissal bid under UPEPA is resolved.
Playtech’s possible exposure in a long-running defamation fight now depends on a court ruling involving a different company. The shift follows a settlement between live casino supplier Evolution and New Jersey law firm Calcagni & Kanefsky LLP.
A court approved the deal at a hearing on November 17. The law firm is now out of the case, leaving investigative firm Black Cube as the only defendant at this stage.
The terms of the settlement are confidential. Next.io reported that neither side has said whether the deal includes a financial payment.
How the Dispute Started
The case goes back to 2021, when Black Cube produced a report about Evolution. The report claimed Evolution’s games were available in markets under sanctions and other restrictions.
Calcagni & Kanefsky sent the document to gaming regulators in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. This led to investigations and wide media coverage.
Evolution denied the claims. It said the report contained misleading information meant to damage its reputation and business.
The company’s share price fell sharply after the report was published. Evolution has since said investigators used deceptive means to get statements from its employees.
It has also said the material was cherry-picked to support claims of regulatory violations. In an earlier step, Evolution tried to identify the people behind the anonymous report.
New Jersey regulators closed their review in February 2024 without taking action against Evolution. The regulator found no evidence the company knowingly let its products operate in banned markets or materially benefited from such activity.
Playtech’s Role and the Path Ahead
In October 2025, court proceedings showed that Playtech had hired Black Cube to investigate Evolution. Playtech admitted using the firm but said it acted in good faith.
Playtech also said the report raised issues that needed to be looked into. The company is a rival supplier to Evolution.
In April 2026, Evolution asked the court for permission to expand its complaint to include Playtech and several other parties. In June, the judge denied that request without prejudice.
That ruling leaves the door open for Evolution to try again. It can do so once proceedings under the Uniform Public Expression Protection Act, known as UPEPA, are finished.
Those proceedings center on Black Cube’s effort to have the lawsuit dismissed. The firm argues that its investigation and the publication of its findings are protected activity.
Black Cube has also pointed to evidence from Evolution’s own internal investigation by Spectrum Gaming. Evolution disputes how those results are being read and questions the reliability of the data used in the original report.
The outcome of Black Cube’s dismissal bid could decide whether Evolution gets another chance to pursue Playtech directly. The settlement with the law firm does not resolve that question.
Playtech shares were volatile after news of the settlement. The stock fell as much as 10% before rebounding ahead of the court proceedings.
