TLDR
- A federal judge dismissed a lawsuit by four Oklahoma tribes against two rival tribes’ gaming compacts.
- Judge Timothy J. Kelly ruled the tribes failed to show actual or imminent harm.
- The 2020 compacts set a flat 4.5% revenue share, down from rates of up to 10%.
- Sports betting and six new casinos under the deals are not in place.
- The compacts’ federal legality remains unresolved, and a state ruling against them still stands.
A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by four Oklahoma tribes against gaming compacts held by two rival tribes. The ruling ends a legal fight that began in 2020.
US District Judge Timothy J. Kelly found that the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw and Citizen Potawatomi nations lacked legal standing. He said they failed to prove the compacts caused them actual or imminent harm.
The decision did not address whether the compacts are legal under federal law. It also left in place an earlier Oklahoma Supreme Court ruling that declared the deals invalid under state law.
How the Dispute Started
The case dates back to 2020, when Republican Governor Kevin Stitt signed new gaming compacts with the Comanche Nation and the Otoe-Missouria Tribe. At the time, he was in a dispute with the state’s other casino-operating tribes over revenue payments.
Stitt wanted tribal casinos to pay the state more. He argued that the model compact signed in 2004 expired on January 1, 2020, and needed to be renegotiated.
The tribes said the 2004 agreements renewed automatically for another 15 years on that date. In October 2021, a federal judge sided with the tribes, and their gaming continued.
The new compacts set a flat 4.5% revenue-sharing rate for most gaming at existing casinos. That was lower than the rates of up to 10% under the model compact.
The deals also included terms for sports betting, more casino games and up to six new gaming sites. Those terms depended on legal and regulatory approvals.
The US Department of the Interior let the compacts take effect in June 2020. It did so by not acting within its 45-day review period, a process called “no-action approval.”
Two months later, the Oklahoma Supreme Court ruled that Stitt had gone beyond his authority. The court said he could not approve gambling that state law still banned, such as sports betting, without the legislature’s consent.
Why the Judge Found No Harm
The four tribes then challenged the federal approvals in court. They argued the compacts gave their competitors an unfair edge.
Kelly disagreed. He noted that the Comanche and Otoe-Missouria already ran casinos before the compacts took effect, so their presence did not add new competition.
He also found that sports betting and the other new games were not being offered. Those games remain unauthorized under Oklahoma law.
The judge called the plans for six new casinos speculative. The federal land-approval process needed for them had not started, according to Casino.org’s report on the ruling.
The plaintiffs also claimed lower revenue payments would let rivals offer bigger jackpots and better amenities. The judge said there was no evidence to support that claim.
Kelly pointed out that tribal gaming revenue often funds government services. It is not always put back into casinos.
The ruling was reported on November 18, 2026. The compacts’ federal legality remains unresolved, while the state court ruling that they are invalid still stands.
