TLDR
- Nine Democratic senators want the CFTC to withdraw its November 5 ban on geofencing by prediction markets.
- They say the rule conflicts with court orders in California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington.
- The rule came hours after a court ordered Kalshi to geofence around two California tribes.
- The senators asked the CFTC to preserve all related records from January 1, 2025, onward.
- The agency has until November 23 to confirm it is keeping those records.
Nine Democratic senators have given the Commodity Futures Trading Commission until November 23 to respond to their demands over prediction markets. The group, led by Senator Adam Schiff of California, wants the agency to withdraw a November 5 interpretation that bans geofencing by prediction market exchanges.
The letter, released by Schiff’s office on November 16, was sent to CFTC Chair Michael Selig. It asks the agency to reverse the interpretation or freeze it until court cases over prediction markets are resolved.
Geofencing lets an exchange block traders based on where they live or are located. The CFTC told designated contract markets to end these location-based limits on certain event contracts within 30 days.
Who Signed the Letter
Schiff, a member of the Senate Agriculture Committee, was joined by every senator from California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington. They include Catherine Cortez Masto, Jacky Rosen, Maria Cantwell, Patty Murray, Elissa Slotkin, Gary Peters and Alex Padilla.
Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, the top Democrat on the Senate Agriculture Committee, also signed. All nine senators are Democrats.
Court orders in those four states currently require prediction market operators to block access to sports event contracts. Some of those orders also cover tribal lands.
The senators say the CFTC’s move would open those contracts to traders in all 50 states and on tribal lands. They argue this directly conflicts with court orders that remain in force.
The letter states that many courts have found sports event contracts are not swaps. Those courts have treated them as sports bets that fall under state and tribal gaming laws.
The senators also point to rulings by the Sixth and Ninth Circuits. Those courts found that states keep the power to apply their gaming laws to prediction markets.
Timing of the Kalshi Ruling
The senators raised concerns about when the interpretation was issued. It came hours after a federal court in Northern California ordered Kalshi to geofence around the lands of two tribes.
The tribes are Blue Lake Rancheria and Chicken Ranch Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians. In September, the Ninth Circuit ruled unanimously that sports contracts on tribal lands likely count as unauthorized Class III gaming under federal law.
The letter says the timing raises concerns that the agency may be coordinating with platforms involved in the lawsuits. This is a claim made by the senators and has not been proven.
At minimum, the senators want the CFTC to clarify three points. They say limits set by court order, limits tied to tribal gaming law or compacts, and limits an exchange adopts on its own should not break the rules.
The group also asked the CFTC to preserve all related records from January 1, 2025, onward. That includes emails, texts, encrypted messaging apps and calendar entries, and the agency was asked to switch off any auto-delete tools.
Braden Perry, a former senior trial attorney at the CFTC, has said such a letter does not carry subpoena power. He noted it does put the agency on formal notice about keeping its records.
Selig has not yet responded to the letter. Before it was sent, he said in a television interview that the CFTC sees prediction markets as within its authority and is ready to defend that view before the Supreme Court.
Other deadlines are close. Responses on whether a Missouri judge should combine four prediction market lawsuits were due November 19, and the CFTC has until November 23 to confirm it is preserving records.
